mcelroy ethics paper

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 13
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Information Report
Category:

Documents

Published:

Views: 6 | Pages: 13

Extension: DOCX | Download: 0

Share
Related documents
Description
McElroy 1 Austin McElroy Dr. Schnee & Dr. Idziak HV Cluster 12/2/16 Prenatal Testing of Beta Thalassemia in China Beta Thalassemia is a disorder that affects red blood cells. The defect occurs most frequently in Mediterranean countries, North Africa, the Middle East, India, Central Asia, and Southeast Asia. China has had a rough time determining how to deal with the beta thalassemia. In China th
Transcript
  McElroy 1Austin McElroyDr. Schnee & Dr. Idziak HV Cluster 12/2/1!renatal estin# o$ %eta halasseia in China%eta halasseia is a disorder that a$$ects red 'lood cells. he de$ect occurs ost$re(uently in Mediterranean countries) *orth A$rica) the Middle East) India) Central Asia) andSoutheast Asia. China has had a rou#h tie deterinin# ho+ to deal +ith the 'eta thalasseia.In China there has 'een any studies lookin# at the e$$ects o$ ,renatal #enetic testin# $or thedisease. he ethical (uestion o$ this ,a,er is should there 'e andatory ,renatal testin# $or 'etathalasseia in China and should a'ortion ha,,en i$ the test is ,ositi-e. his ,a,er +ill use ,rinci,lis as the ethical theory that the ar#uents +ill 'e 'ased one) usin# the ,rinci,les o$  'ene$icence) nonale$icence) and autonoy to deterine to ethics o$ undertakin# ,renatal tests. his is 'ecause o$ their needs to 'e 'ene$icent to+ards the children that ha-e this disease. irst itis i,ortant to understand the thalasseia and kno+ 'oth the 'ene$its and costs o$ ha-in# it.%eta thalasseia is a #enetic disorder that reduces the ,roduction o$ an ironcontainin# ,rotein called Heo#lo'in. Heo#lo'in carries iron throu#h the 'lood strea. his is due toutations in the heo#lo'in su'unit 'eta 0H%% #ene) a #ene +hich includes the instructions $or creatin# 'eta#lo'in. hree 'eta#ol'in are e$$ected 'y the disease. +o o$ the 'eta #ol'in aredeleted +ith the third 'ein# utated 0enetics Hoe 3e$erence. he lack o$ these cells leads to$e+er red 'lood cells) +hich causes aneia and iron o-erdoses. he treatent o$ the disease can-ary 'ased o$$ its e4,ression o$ the #enes. or the ild -ersion o$ the disease the treatent isoccasional 'lood trans$usions or oral edication. here also are si,le solutions that can hel, tokee, the disease to a iniu) such as re#ular e4ercise and a diet that contains little iron. Morese-ere cases need re#ular 'lood trans$usions and ,ossi'ly 'one arro+ trans$usion. 5ithout  McElroy 2these treatents carriers o$ the disease can e4,erience iron o-erload) +hich causes trou'le heart)li-er) and endocrine syste) and 'e at #reater risk $or in$ection. he se-ere cases ha-e e-en ore ,ro'les. hose include enlar#ed 'ones and s,leen) slo+ed #ro+th rate) a'noral heart rhythsand con#esti-e heart $ailure 0Mayo Clinic. Ho+e-er it has 'een sho+n that the disease can 'eana#ea'le in all $ors and there is a decreased ortality rate i$ dia#nosed early. A lot o$ thesesy,tos and solutions coe $ro $irst +orld edical institutions 06al) oldrich) Haines)2711. Each year 87777 in$ants are 'orn +ith 'eta thalasseia and 287 illion ,eo,le arecarriers o$ #enes 0E Cousens) *icole E.) Clara 6. a$$) Syl-ia A. Metcal$e) & !eter Har,er)2717. !o,ulations in de-elo,in# areas) such as rural China) has seen any cases o$ 'etathalasseia.%eta halasseia 'een dia#nosed ,riarily in rural and de-elo,in# ,arts o$ south eastChina. 3esearchers in 2719 $ound that ,atients +ith 'eta thalasseia in uan#4i :huan# ,ro-ince o$ China had 8;.< o$ the deletional $or o$ the disease and 2=.=< had thenondeletional $or o$ the disease 0an#) Chen) :en#) ian) >ian#) 6i) Chen) Du and Chen) 2719. he 8;.< o$ those +ith 'eta thalasseia +ere dealin# +ith the ,ro'les o$ aneia and irono-erdoses. Most in China do deal +ith these issues +ith re#ular 'lood trans$usions 0Chan#an#6) Chunu 6) ?i 6) Min# 6. 2778. 3esearchers Chan#an# 6) Chunu 6) ?i 6) and Min# 6.02778 ha-e 'een studyin# 'eta thalasseia in south China and ho+ ,eo,le in those re#ions deal+ith the disease. here is also a $ocus o$ traditional Chinese her'al edication. or e4a,le theyuse @isuishen#4ue ranules) and her's such as sco,olaine and sodiu $erulateB 0,.977. his ,rolon#s the li$e s,an o$ the red 'lood cells. here is still the ,ro'le +ith the disease. hereason $or the s,read o$ thalasseia in these areas is due to the ,re-alence o$ alaria in these hotand huid cliates.  McElroy 9ne #rou, o$ researchers 06iao) :hou) ie) an#) 6i) 6i. 271= ran a andatory #enetictestin# on in$ants in uan#don# ,ro-ince. he testin# +as done $ro >anuary 2717 to Dece'er 2711. he t+o 'i##est +ere uan#4i) +ith =8 out o$ 2= testin# ,ositi-e) and uan#don#) +ith=82 out o$ =)91 testin# ,ositi-e. he rest o$ the ,ro-idences screened had less than 17< tested ,ositi-e. Soe o$ the ,ro-idences +ith lar#e cities) such as Shan#hai) only had 1 tested and 1$ound ,ositi-e.Studies done $or testin# $or 'eta thalasseia in China ha-e 'een conducted a nuerousnu'er o$ +ays. ne research #rou, 0Chan#an# 6) et. al. 2778 discussed China usin# a t+oste, syste to test $or the disease in ne+'orns. he $irst screenin# is a red 'lood cell $ra#ilitytest) +hich has a $alse ne#ati-e ;..1< 0Chan#an# 6) et. al. 2778. he second ste, is a H'electro,horesis to con$ir ,ositi-e cases. his test can also iss H' H althou#h the researchdoes not include the statistics o$ ho+ any are issed 0Chan#an# 6) et. al. 2778. he ,ro'le is that there are any su'ty,es o$ thalasseia that akes it di$$icult to $ind carriers and+hat the e4,ressi-ity o$ the disease 0Chan#an# 6) et. al. 2778. he edical ,ro'les that thechild +ill ha-e to deal +ith also cannot 'e deterined 'y the test.3esearcher Slee'ooaulkner 02717 looked a assi-e nu'er o$ Chinese eu#enics ,re#nancy hand'ooks to deterine +hat ,re#nant +oen +ere learnin# a'out. Slee'ooaulkner $ound that in soe 'ooks @indi-iduals are encoura#ed to ake choices ad-anta#eous tothesel-es) +hile at the sae tie) and ore i,ortantly) su,,ortin# the collecti-e #oal o$ i,ro-in# the Chinese stockB 0,.191. A lot o$ the hand'ooks e,hasis #ettin# a ,renatalchecku, in order to ensure an @intelli#ent) 'eauti$ul) healthy and li-ely childB 0,.199. or theost ,art these hand'ooks e,hasize that China is a odern and ad-anced society that needs tocontinue to ad-ance in the odern +orld. $ course these social trends raise the issue that coe  McElroy =u, +ith testin# $or a #enetic disease. 5hile the child is not a noral @healthyB 'a'y it is still achild can #ro+ u, li-in# a li$e +ith a ana#ea'le condition. his ,a,er +ill use ,rinci,lis as the 'asis $or oral Fud#ent on andatory ,renataltestin# o$ 'eta thalasseia in China. !rinci,lis is a set o$ @#eneral #uidelines $or the $orationo$ the ore s,eci$ic rulesB 0%eaucha, & Childress. 2771. ,.12 and are @intended to e4,ress#eneral nors o$ the coon orality that are a suita'le startin# ,oint $or 'ioedical ethicsB0%eaucha, & Childress. 2771. ,.12. here are $our oral ,rinci,les that one has to a,,ly+hen akin# a oral decision. hey are res,ect $or autonoy) nonale$icence) 'ene$icence)and Fustice 0%eaucha, & Childress. 2771. his ,a,er +ill use three o$ ,rinci,les. 3es,ect $or autonoy) +hich eans that indi-iduals ha-e the ri#ht to ake an in$ored decision $or thesel-es. *onale$icence +hich eans that @one ou#ht not to in$lict e-il or harB0%eaucha, & Childress. 2771. ,.1;1. And 'ene$icence +hich has any ,arts that are @oneou#ht to ,re-ent e-il or harGone ou#ht to reo-e e-il or harGone to do or ,roote #ood0%eaucha, & Childress. 2771. ,.1;1. sin# these three ,rinci,les) 'ene$icence)nonale$icence) and autonoy the ethics o$ andatory ,renatal screenin# +ith the ,ossi'ility o$ a'ortion +ill 'e e4ained. here is a lot o$ ar#uents a#ainst usin# +estern ,hiloso,hy in China +hich does nothold the sae -alues as the +est. he 5estern ,hiloso,hy and Chinese ,hiloso,hy di$$er in +hatthey see as the ost i,ortant. or the Chinese it should 'e the state $irst rather than theindi-idual) +here in the 5est it is the o,,osite 03od#ers. 12. 5estern edicine is 'ased onthe ethics o$ 'ene$icence and nonale$icence. here is also a $ocus on the i,ortance o$ theri#hts o$ indi-idual. 5hile in China there is an e,hasis on the ideals o$ oral sel$disci,line. In#eneral the issue is that the Chinese ha-e an e,hasis that the indi-idual should 'e orally
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks