Republic v. Acoje Mining | Negligence | Estoppel

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 1
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Information Report
Category:

Documents

Published:

Views: 7 | Pages: 1

Extension: DOCX | Download: 0

Share
Related documents
Description
Republic v. Acoje Mining
Transcript
  Republic of the Phils. vs Acoje Mining G.R. No. L-18062 / February 28, 1963 / Bautista Angeo, !./ #R$#RA%&$#'&R(/F)ARGA( NA%*R& A++ea$&%%#N&R( Republic of the Philippines R&($#N&N%(  Acoje Mining Company  SUMMARY  . o+any ase te Bureaus o $osts to o+en a +ost o4e in (ta. ru5, abaes. ire4tor o $osts i+ose se7era 4onitions, one o i4 is tat te 4o+any assues ire4t res+onsibiity or ate7er +e4uniary oss ay be suere by te Bureau o $osts by reason o any a4to isonesty, 4areessness or negigen4e on te +art o te e+oyee o te 4o+any o is assigne to tae 4arge o te +ost o4e. %e 4o+any agree. (ubse:uenty, te +ostaster ire by te 4o+any stoe a ot o 4as. o+any a7ers tat tey are not res+onsibe be4ause te B# resoution agreeing to te 4onition o te ire4tor o $osts as utra 7ires. DOCTRIN. ourt e;+aine tat utra 7ires a4ts are <ust 7oiabe an not 7oi an te reso is not ne4essariy utra 7ires be4ause a 4or+ 4an enter into transa4tions bene=4ia to it. At te east te 4o+any 4annot is4ai iabiity on te groun o esto++e- tey a7e areay re4ei7e bene=ts. !ACTS. ã A4o<e >ining o+any, n4. re:ueste te ire4tor o $osts to o+en a+ost, teegra+ an oney orer o4es at its ining 4a+ at (ta. ru5, abaes, to ser7i4e its e+oyees an teir aiies tat erei7ing in sai 4a+. ã ire4tor e;+aine tat it is teir +oi4y tat te 4o+any assuesire4t res+onsibiity or ate7er +e4uniary oss ay be suere byte Bureau o $osts by reason o any a4t o isonesty, 4areessness ornegigen4e on te +art o te e+oyee o te 4o+any o isassigne to tae 4arge o te +ost o4e. ã B# +asse a resoution ?agreeing to te 4onitions@%at te re:uireent o te Bureau o $osts tat te 4o+any soua44e+t u res+onsibiity or a 4as re4ei7e by te $ostaster, be4o+ie it, an tat a 4o+y o tis resoution be orare to teBureau o $osts. ã  %e bran4 as o+ene it Ciario >. (an4e5, an e+oyee o te4o+any, as +ostaster. Ce ent on a 3 ay ea7e but ne7er returne.A++arenty, e abs4one it $13,86D.2E. ã o+any int +ay u+ es+ite se7era eans ?reeber teyassue iabiity@ so te go7ernent ent to 4ourt. ã o+any %e resoution o te B# as utra 7ires. %ey are asoiabe ony as a guarantor an te +ro+erties o te +rin4i+a nee to bee;auste =rst. ã F ony te su o $9,1.2 as su++orte by te e7ien4e- so tisis at 4o+any ougt to +ay. ISSUS RATIO .1.Was the resolution ultra vires? No. 'ie as a rue an utra 7ires a4t is one 4oitte outsie te ob<e4tor i4 a 4or+oration is 4reate as e=ne by te a o itsorgani5ation an tereore beyon te +oers 4onerre u+on it by atere are  however certain corporate acts that may be performedoutside of the scope of the powers expressly conferred if theyare necessary to promote the interest or welfare of thecorporation - tis 4ase or e;a+e.t as te 4o+anys iea to o+en a bran4 tere or te bene=t o itse+oyees. t asnt te Go7ernent o 4ae to te 4o+any. t ise7ient tat te 4o+any 4annot no be ear to 4o+ain tat it is notiabe or te irreguarity 4oitte by its e+oyee u+on te te4ni4a+ea tat te resoution a++ro7e by its boar o ire4tors is utra 7ires. %eeast tat 4an be sai is tat it 4annot no go ba4 on its +igte or onte groun o esto++e. %e estabisent o te o4a +ost o4e is a reasonabe an +ro+era<un4t to te 4onu4t o te business o 4o+any ?tey neee a +ost toser7i4e e+oyees  te reote area@. An utra 7ires a4t is erey 7oiabe, 4o+are to an iega a4t i4 is7oi. %e resoution ere is not 7oi or it as a++ro7e not in4ontra7ention o a, 4ustos, +ubi4 orer or +ubi4 +oi4y.t being erey 7oiabe, an utra 7ires a4t 4an be enor4e or 7aiate i tere are e:uitabe grouns or taing su4 a4tion. Cere it is air tat teresoution be u+e at east on te groun o esto++e-te 4o+any asareay re4ei7e bene=ts. %e eense o utra 7ires rests on 7ioation o trust or uty toarsto4oers, an sou not be entertaine ere its aoan4e i ogreater rong to inno4ent +arties eaing it 4or+orationLasty, te 4o+any assue Hu res+onsibiity or a 4as re4ei7e by te$ostaster.H- ob7iousy not a <ust a guarantor. DCISION . Loer ourt Are.
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks