Using prospectively collected data beginning during the week

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 6
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Information Report
Category:

Government & Politics

Published:

Views: 0 | Pages: 6

Extension: PDF | Download: 0

Share
Related documents
Description
The long shadow cast by childhood physical and mental problems on adult life Alissa Goodman a, Robert Joyce a, and James P. Smith b,1 a Institute for Fiscal Studies, London WC1E 7AE, United Kingdom; and
Transcript
The long shadow cast by childhood physical and mental problems on adult life Alissa Goodman a, Robert Joyce a, and James P. Smith b,1 a Institute for Fiscal Studies, London WC1E 7AE, United Kingdom; and b RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA Edited by Kenneth Wachter, University of California, Berkeley, CA, and approved February 8, 2011 (received for review November 11, 2010) In this article we assess and compare long-term adult socioeconomic status impacts from having experienced psychological and physical health problems in childhood. To do so, we use unique prospective data from the British National Child Development Study, a continuing panel study of a cohort of 17,634 children born in Great Britain during a single week in March To date there have been nine waves for this birth cohort to monitor their physical, educational, and social development, during childhood (at birth and 7, 11, and 16 y) and adulthood (age 23, 33, 42, 46, and 50 y). Excellent contemporaneous information exists throughout childhood on physical and psychological health, captured by doctor and nurse-led medical examinations and detailed parental and teacher questionnaires. This information is combined with a wealth of contemporaneous information on adult health and economic experiences collected from cohort members. Information includes their economic circumstances (earnings, labor supply, and other sources of family income), physical and psychological health, and relationship status. Large effects are found due to childhood psychological problems on the ability of affected children to work and earn as adults and on intergenerational and withingeneration social mobility. Adult family incomes are reduced by 28% by age 50 y, with sustained impacts on labor supply, marriage stability, and the conscientiousness and agreeableness components of the Big Five personality traits. Effects of psychological health disorders during childhood are far more important over a lifetime than physical health problems. Using prospectively collected data beginning during the week of birth, repeated at three additional ages in childhood and adolescence, and extended into adulthood to age 50 y, this study investigates long-term adult impacts of having experienced psychological and physical health problems during childhood. Stimulated by the work of Barker (1), recent research has established evidence of a strong link between various aspects of poor physical health during childhood (and even in utero) and adult health (2 7) and economic outcomes later during adulthood (8, 9). Much less studied have been long-term health and socioeconomic (SES) consequences of psychological conditions experienced during childhood (10, 11). This is even more surprising given the substantial rise in psychological disorders affecting young people in the United Kingdom in the past 25 y (12, 13). Recently, Smith and Smith (14) used retrospective questions in the American Panel Study of Income Dynamics to find that impacts of childhood psychological problems on adult SES are large a lifetime cost in lost family income of approximately $300,000 and total lifetime economic cost for all those affected of $2.1 trillion. An advantage of that study is that it compared siblings, so it was able to control for unobserved family and neighborhood effects, which were found not to be critical for this question. A disadvantage of that research is that it relied on retrospective self-reports of childhood physical and psychological problems, reports that could be colored by adult experiences, including those in the psychological domain. That disadvantage will be rectified here by using prospective panel data measuring at key points in childhood and adulthood the physical and psychological health of respondents alongside measures of the family and economic circumstances of their lives. Model Data. The National Child Development Study (NCDS) is a continuing longitudinal study following lives of a single cohort of 17,634 children born in Britain during 1 week of March 1958 (15). To date there have been nine waves of data collection to monitor their physical, educational, and social development. Four waves took place during childhood (birth and 7, 11, and 16 y) and five waves during adult years (age 23, 33, 42, 46, and 50 y). Seventyone percent of the original respondents were in the study at the fifth wave, and discrimination between responders and nonresponders had not been marked (16). We do not use the age- 46-y wave because it lacks some of our main SES outcomes [family income, social security receipts, and gross hourly wages (a routing error meant that 70% of earners were not asked how many hours per week they work)]. This study collected excellent contemporaneous information in childhood on physical and psychological health through doctor-led medical examinations, detailed parental questionnaires, teacher reports, and health visitors. The data contain a very rich set of information on parents, including parental SES and family circumstances (including family breakdown and instability in the home). In adulthood, NCDS collects contemporaneous information on respondents current economic circumstances (earnings, labor supply, and other sources of family income), physical and psychological health, relationship status, and at age 50 y, cognitive and noncognitive traits. The intent of NCDS was to follow all children born in Britain who were still alive and did not permanently migrate. Initial nonresponse at time of birth was remarkably low less than 1% (17). Attrition in NCDS was also relatively small. At age 42 y, 71% of the target sample was interviewed. Attrition during adult years was especially quite low, with 91% of the age-23-y population still in the study at age 42 y. Hawkes and Plewis (18) show that in terms of observable attributes there are few differences in probability of retention between those who left the study and those who remained. Measures. This study relies on repeated measurement of several key domains of individual s lives in childhood and adulthood. These domains include psychological and physical health during childhood and adult years; information about family background in which the children grew up; and the principal indicators of SES during adulthood, including education, employment status, wages, and family income. Childhood Health Measures. The first set of key NCDS measures involves those collected about respondents psychological and physical health in childhood. For psychological health, medical examinations captured emotional maladjustment (at ages 7 and 16 y), and parent reports captured whether the child had been Author contributions: A.G., R.J., and J.P.S. designed research, performed research, analyzed data, and wrote the paper. The authors declare no conflict of interest. This article is a PNAS Direct Submission. 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed PNAS April 12, 2011 vol. 108 no. 15 seen by a psychologist or psychiatrist (ages 11 and 16 y). In medical examinations, doctors judged degree of maladjustment to be none, a problem but no handicap to ordinary schooling, a slight problem, a moderate problem, or a severe problem. We count moderate or severe problems only, to be consistent with our coding of childhood physical problems (see below). Using this information, we create an indicator variable equal to 1 if any psychological problems existed up to age 16 y and 0 otherwise. Thus, if a doctor detects a degree of emotional maladjustment that is moderate or severe at age 7 or 16 y, or if the parent reports the child has seen a psychologist or psychiatrist at age 11 or 16 y, we conclude that a child had a psychological problem by age 16 y. We use data about several aspects of physical health problems at ages 7, 11, and 16 y. These cover a wide range of conditions, including severe headaches or migraines, skin abnormalities, other physical abnormalities, speech defects, hearing defects, vision defects, epilepsy, asthma, diabetes, other respiratory problems, urinary problems, heart disease, and digestive problems. Because of low prevalence rates of some physical conditions, we aggregate them into nine categories for our analysis: eye, ear, and skin conditions; asthma and other respiratory problems; headaches and migraines; speech defects; physical abnormalities; alimentary, urogenital, and blood problems; epilepsy and other central nervous system conditions; heart abnormalities; and any other conditions. Where a scale of severity is available, we exclude anything indicating no handicap or a slight handicap. We make one exception, for heart conditions, where slight problems are included on the basis that any heart problem is serious for a child. At ages 7 and 16 y, this information comes from doctor assessments, with the exceptions of asthma and headaches or migraines, which are reported by parents of cohort members. At age 11 y, the information we use comes mostly from parent reports to a medical examiner (medical examinations were also carried out at this age, but they are not generally comparable with those at ages 7 and 16 y), with the exception of hearing defects, for which we use medical assessments. Adult Health Measures. Adult follow-ups ask cohort members for an assessment of their general health, which can be rated as poor, fair, good, or excellent. Only 18% of respondents report less than good health, so we count both poor and fair as indicators of substandard general health. Adult follow-ups also include detailed assessments of psychological well-being, based on instruments such as the Malaise Inventory (19) and the General Health Questionnaire. The Malaise Inventory is a 24 yes no question scale based on factors such as whether a respondent is often irritated, worried, frightened, often depressed, annoyed, jittery, has sleep problems, has violent rages, has had a nervous breakdown, lets things get on their nerves, etc. Internal consistency and validity of the malaise inventory scale was shown to hold for different SES groups (20). Following the normal convention, we create a dummy variable, which is equal to 1 if the number of affirmative responses in the Malaise Inventory is greater than seven. The General Health Questionnaire is a 12-question scale based on factors such as concentration, losing sleep, confidence, under strain, feeling depressed, happy, worthless, self-perceived capability, etc. (21, 22) that has been favorably tested for reliability and validity (23). For each of the 12 questions, responses are measured on a Likert scale and can score anything from 0 to 3 (not at all, no more than usual, rather more than usual, much more than usual). Total score is then summed across the 12 questions. A score 15 indicates psychological distress. A score 20 indicates severe psychological distress. Dummy variables for each of these are created. Family Background Measures. Besides health, our data contain several salient measures on the background in which children were raised. The variables that we label family structure variables include age, number of years in education of both parents; occupation status (SES) of father, marital status of mother at child s birth (married, never married, widowed/separated/divorced); whether a first-born; a twin; an only child; grew up with older brothers or sisters; number of people in household; whether breastfed; whether birth weight was low ( 88 oz); mother is obese (body mass index 30 kg/m 2 ) or a heavy smoker before pregnancy; ethnicity (white or nonwhite); whether English is first language normally spoken by mother and child; region of residence; and early developmental indicators, such as age of walking, speech, and toilet training. Because low birth weight can be viewed as a physical health problem, we present estimated coefficients on low birth weight. We also include in models extensive measures of family difficulties during childhood: dummy variables for whether family had difficulties related to housing; financial; physical illness or disability; death of child s parent; divorce, separation, or desertion; domestic tension; unemployment; alcoholism, mental illness or neurosis, or mental subnormality in family; and any other serious difficulties affecting child s development. Adult Outcome Measures. Our central adult SES outcome is family income (net of taxes and including government transfers) measured in natural logs so that coefficients are percent changes. Family income is arguably the most comprehensive measure of economic resources and is the best measure of economic impacts of childhood health. Family income is principally made up of respondents earnings (hourly wages times hours worked) and any contribution to family income of a spouse/partner. To understand the relative importance of the components, we examine models of respondents natural log (ln) hourly wages (of workers) and employment probability. To assess contributions of spouses/ partners, we examine at each wave whether there is a partner, partner s education, and the probability partner is employed. Family income is not the only useful index of economic advancement. There are two aspects of social mobility examined intergenerational and within an adult life span. For intergenerational mobility, we compared both occupation status and education of respondents with that of the father when respondent was a child. Occupation is divided into five ordered groups: professional; managerial-technical; skilled; partly skilled; unskilled. Education is school-leaving age minus five. For occupation and education, we defined two binary outcomes equal to 1 if the cohort member is in a higher (lower) occupational class (education) class at age 42 y than father. Within-career social mobility was defined by whether occupation status was higher or lower at age 42 y than at age 23 y, using the same five-group occupation status. Thereismoretolifethaneconomics,sowealsomodelnoneconomic outcomes mostly measured at age 50 y. These are as follows: number of words out of 10 correctly recalled (measure of cognitive function); Big Five noncognitive traits extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, emotional stability, and intellect measured using the International Personality Item Pool inventory (20); and dummy variables for whether individuals usually get what they want out of life and whether they can run life more or less as they want. Statistical Methods. We estimate ordinary least squares models for continuous outcomes and probit models for binary outcomes relating existence of childhood physical and physiological health issues to adult SES outcomes in NCDS at ages 23, 33, 42, and 50 y. Estimating models at ages spanning from young adulthood into middle age allows us to trace evolving impacts of childhood health issues as respondents age. To account for heteroscedasticity and outliers, we ran all analyses using robust SEs and experimented with deletion of outliers. The essentials of our findings were unchanged. All tests of statistical significance use robust SEs. ECONOMIC SCIENCES Goodman et al. PNAS April 12, 2011 vol. 108 no We take advantage of panel data in several ways. First, we include models of between-age growth in ln family income. Second, we model outcomes combining data from several waves, including intergenerational occupational and education mobility and withincareer occupational mobility, defined above. We also model number of waves respondents were unemployed, number of distinct job spells (a job is continuous employment with same employer) since age 23 y, and marriage stability (with the same partner at ages 42 and 33 y). Fixed effects estimation is not possible because individuals have only one childhood which cannot be differenced. Random-effects models produced essentially the same empirical estimates as those reported here. Our key explanatory variables are having a childhood psychological disorder and the set of physical childhood health problems described above. Our models include all family structure and difficulties attributes listed above and sex of respondent. Including these family attributes means that estimated impacts of childhood physical and mental health are independent of these measurable problems in the family home environment during childhood. Results The top two rows of Table 1 list estimated effects of having any childhood psychological problem by age 16 y on two salient indicators of adult economic success ln of net family income and ln of hourly wage (using a sample of workers). Separate parameter estimates for both economic outcomes are listed for ages 23, 33, 42, and 50 y. There are several salient patterns. First, childhood psychological problems have a significant negative impact on both economic outcomes measures, producing 14 28% lower incomes or wages from early adulthood into middle age (24). Second, a significant part of the estimated negative effects of childhood psychological problems are present at the beginning of adulthood. The initial negative impact at age 23 y of 19% lower family income is two thirds as large as the estimated effect on net family income at age 50 y. This large initial effect compared with long-term effect is even more evident for hourly wages. Third, the estimated effect on family income is larger than on hourly wages, and the difference between the two grows with age. In the third row of Table 1, we summarize a model of betweenage annual percent growth in family income. Similar to separate age-specific models, a large part of negative impacts of childhood mental problems is present at the beginning of adulthood (age 23 y), but there are negative decrements after that age, particularly in the early phase of the career. Models in Table 1 estimating probability of employment and probability of living with a partner demonstrate that key sources of family income loss are a lower probability of being employed (10) and a lower probability of living with a partner (14). We also find that childhood mental health problems decrease partnership stability because the probability one is living with the same partner at ages 42 and 33 y (if partnered at age 33 y) is reduced. For those with a partner, we estimate a lower probability that a partner is employed and a lower partner education level. By age 50 y, those with childhood psychological problems experienced an 11 percentage point lower probability of working and a 6 percentage point lower probability of being married or cohabiting. All this helps explain why the negative effect of psychological problems on total net family income increases with age and is larger than estimated effects on hourly wages alone. Table 2 compares estimated effects of childhood psychological problems on ln family income with estimates of impacts of childhood physical health problems on the same outcome. For comparative purposes, estimates for a psychological problem from Table 1 are placed in the first line in Table 2. Estimated family income effects of physical health problems seem in general to be much less than those of mental health problems because only a small number of physical problems have consistently significant negative effects throughout the life cycle. The most notable are speech defects and epilepsy or other central nervous system conditions, as well as other not specified, but the latter two have very low prevalence. This conclusion is confirmed in Table 3, in which we aggregate physical health problems into three subcategories minor, major, and low birth weight to provide a more direct comparison with our catch-all measure of psychological problems. Low birth weight has consistently negative impacts on adult family income, and estimated effects of minor physical problems are smaller than those of major physical health problems. However, the starkest pattern remains the same estimated effects of childhood psychological problems on net family income thr
Recommended
View more...
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks